GEN
Star Wars FAQ
This FAQ has been compiled
in an effort to provide answers to frequently asked questions
with regards to Star Wars. It is not intended to be the
ultimate guide to all things Star Wars and, in some cases,
is not the final answer. This FAQ is taken, in part,
from the one compiled for the alt.fan.starwars newsgroup
and as I had a fairly big hand in its creation I see no reason
in not using it here.
Special
thanks for this FAQ go to Brian Bagley, John
Donchig, Michael B. Mayo, Stephen G. Harrogate-Bramley,
Andrew Pollock, Brett McConnie and Jerry
Dallapè. But THIS particular version owes
more to Brett McConnie, so thank you Brett.
The FAQ is divided into three relevant categories:
Episodes I-III, Episodes IV-VI and Miscellaneous.
Frequently
Asked Questions
GEN
Version 1 - December, 2007
*1*
EPISODES I-III *1*
1.A
- What is the Force (metachlorians, midichlorians, whatever)?
1.B - In Duel of the Fates, what language is
that?
1.C - Who is Anakin's father?
1.D - Why does Obi-Wan say Yoda was his teacher
in ESB but in TPM it's Qui-Gon?
1.E - What's this about bringing balance to
the Force?
1.F - Why doesn't Qui-Gon disappear?
1.G- Was that Qui-Gon's voice that Yoda heard
when Anakin killed the Tusken Raiders?
1.H- Who is Sifo-Dyas and who erased Kamino
from the Jedi Archives?
1.I - Why was Count Dooku surprised by the appearance
of the clone army when he knew Jango Fett?
1.J - What happened to Jango's unaltered clone?
1.K - If General Grievous is a droid why does
he cough?
1.L - Which is Palpatine's real face?
1.M - How is Leia able to remember her mother
when Padmé died after childbirth?
*2*
EPISODES IV-VI *2*
2.A
- Are Bail, Wedge and Captain Antilles related?
2.B - Didn't the droids belong to Wedge?
2.C - What does Darth Vader mean?
2.D - Why did Obi-Wan lie about the droids?
2.E - Are Imperial Stormtroopers clones?
2.F - Why doesn't Owen recognize the droids?
2.G - When did Vader find out about Luke?
2.H - Who said the numbers `3263827` in the
Trash Compactor?
2.I - What is Yoda?
2.J - Is the Emperor a Jedi? Who trained him?
2.K- How long was Luke on Dagobah?
2.L - Who originally played Emperor Palpatine
in ESB?
2.M - In the Carbon Freezing Chamber scene in
ESB, when Vader says "I am altering the deal," does
he use the Force to choke Lando?
2.N - Are Obi-Wan and Owen Lars brothers?
2.O - Did Boba Fett really die in ROTJ?
*3*
MISCELLANEOUS *3*
3.A
- What is meant by "canon"?
3.B - Will there be episodes 7-9?
3.C - Missing scenes?
3.D - What is "Troops"?
3.E - What is the "Star Wars Holiday Special"?
3.F - Mark Hamill's accident.
3.G - How do you spell litesabber....lightsaybr....lights...pagh!!!
3.H - I've heard such and such happens in the
novels/graphic novels but which one?
3.I - What time period do the films cover and
what are the ages of the major characters?
3.J - Why can't I get the original unaltered
trilogy on DVD?
3.K - What does EU stand for?
3.L - Easter Eggs?
3.M - Did Mark Hamill shout "Carrie"
in Episode IV?
*1* EPISODES I - III *1*
1.A
- What is the Force (metachlorians, midichlorians, whatever)?
The
following is an excerpt taken from the Toronto Sun
(Bob Thompson, 6/1/99)
"The scientific Star Wars explanation," says
Lucas, "is that the midichlorians can hear the Force,
and they communicate with cells, and cells communicate with
your consciousness."
In TPM Qui-Gon attempts to explain the nature of the Force
to Anakin.
"Midichlorians
are microscopic lifeforms that reside within all living cells...
And
we are symbionts with them, life-forms living together for
mutual advantage... Without
the midichlorians, life could not exist, and we would have
no knowledge of the Force. They continually speak to us, telling
us the will of the Force."
1.B
- In Duel of the Fates, what language is that?
Excerpt
from http://www.jwilliamsmusic.it/jwchat.htm
Ask
Lucasfilm: Jedi-Andy says: "In duel of
the fates, what language is that?"
John
Williams: "That is Sanskrit. Simply, because I
liked the way it sounded, in part, and in part, because it's
an ancient language less well-known than Latin or Greek. It
also has good vowel sounds, which produce good tone and timbre
from the chorus, similar to modern Italian. Sanskrit, by the
way, is the root language of India".
i)
Why Sanskrit?
Sanskrit
originated in the northern India/Nepal region during the 3rd
Century AD. The Brahman caste used it during Hindu religious
ceremonies. It serves to achieve oneness, a connecting of
self with the world soul. People often use it in theatrical
productions because of its mythic tone.
ii)
What are the Sanskrit words?
From:
Angelo Muredda
Newsgroup: alt.fan.starwars
Subject: Re: What are the words in "Duel of the Fates"
(on the soundtrack?)
Date: Sat, Jun 3, 1999, 8:30 AM
The
words -as sung- are:
"Korah Matah Korah Rahtahmah
Korah Rahtamah Yoodhah Korah
Korah Syahdho Rahtahmah Daanya
Korah Keelah Daanyah Nyohah Keelah Korah Rahtahmah
Syadho Keelah Korah Rahtahmah
Korah Daanyah Korah Rahtahmah
Korah Daanyah Korah Rahtahmah
Nyohah Keelah Korah Rahtahmah
Syadho Keelah Korah Rahtahmah
Korah Korah Matah Korah Rahtahmah
Korah Daanyah Korah Rahtahmah
Nyohah Keelah Korah Rahtahmah
Syadho Keelah Korah Rahtahmah
Korah"
iii)
What is the English translation?
From:
Wes Leavell
Newsgroup: alt.fan.starwars
Subject: Re: Duel of the Fates...lyrics? -HERE THEY ARE
Date: Fri, May 28, 1999, 10:23 PM
Ok,
did some research. Here ya go. The original text for the words
comes from "Cad Goddeu" an old Celtic poem -translation
Battle of the Trees or depending on the meaning of trees,
especially from a more druidic sense Battle of the Fates.
The english translation of the lyrics used is:
"Under the tongue root, a fight most dread, and another
raging behind, in the head."
This was translated to rhyme, a more direct translation without
keeping the meter and rhyme is:
"Beneath the tongue of the tree, a grave battle unfolds,
and another begins: the fire in the head."
These lyrics -the rhyming english translation by Robert Graves-
were then translated again into a dead dialect -sorry dont
know the name of it, only that its written
form was sanskrit. Several older dialects used the same writing.
iv)
What is the "Battle of the Trees"?
BATTLE
OF THE TREES
The
Battle of the Trees is a Welsh poem reconstructed from mixed
and fragmentary evidence by Robert Graves, a noted expert
on mythology - especially Greek. The second chapter of Graves's
White Goddess, a work on myth that George Lucas has praised
now and then along with Frazer's Golden Bough and Campbell's
Hero with a Thousand Faces, describes the reconstruction of
this poem. Later chapters elicit its mythological and historical
meaning.
Cbd
Goddeu
'The
Battle of the Trees'
From
Robert Graves, The White Goddess, New York: The Noonday Press
(Farrar, Straus & Giroux), 1966. Pages 33-38.
The
tops of the beech tree
Have sprouted of late
Are changed and renewed, from their withered state.
When the beech prospers
Though spells and litanies
The oak tops entangle
There is hope for trees.
I have plundered the fern
Through all secrets I spy
Old Math ap Mathonwy
Knew no more than I
For with nine sorts of faculty
God has gifted me:
I am fruit of fruits gathered
From nine sorts of tree
Plum, quince, whortle, mulberry
Raspberry, pear
Black cherry and white
With the sorb in me share
From my seat at Fefynedd
A city that is strong
I watched the trees and green things
Hastening along
Retreating from happiness
They would fain be set
In forms of the chief letters
Of the alphabet
Wayfarers wondered
Warriors were dismayed
At renewal of conflicts
Such as Gwydion made
Under the tongue root
A fight most dread
And another raging
Behind, in the head
The alders in the front line
Began the affray
Willow and rowan-tree
Were tardy in array
The holly, dark green
Made a resolute stand
He is armed with many spear points
Wounding the hand.
With foot-beat of the swift oak
Heaven and earth rung
'Stout Guardian of the Door'
His name in every tongue
Great was the gorse in battle
And the ivy at his prime
The hazel was arbiter
At this charmed time
Uncouth and savage was the fir
Cruel the ash tree
Turns not aside a foot-breadth
Straight at the heart runs he
The birch, though very noble
Armed himself but late
A sign not of cowardice
But of high estate
The heath gave consolation
To the toil-spent folk
The long-enduring poplars
In battle much broke
Some of them were cast away
On the field of fight
Because of holes torn in them
By the enemy's might
Very wrathful was the vine
Whose henchmen are the elms
I exalt him mightily
To rulers of realms
Strong chieftains were the blackthorn
With his ill fruit
The unbeloved whitethorn
Who wears the same suit
The swift-pursuing reed
The broom with his brood
And the furze but ill-behaved
Until he is subdued
The dower-scattering yew
Stood glum at the fight's fringe
With the elder slow to burn
Amid fires that singe
And the blessed wild apple
Laughing in pride
From the Gorchan of Maeldrew
By the rock side
In shelter linger
Privet and woodbine
Inexperienced in warfare
And the courtly pine
But I, although slighted
Because I was not big
Fought, trees, in your array
On the field of
Goddeu Brig.
From
page 123 of the same volume, a description of the basic meaning
- read the book for more!: "I first suspected that
an alphabet was contained in Gwion's conundrum when I began
to restore the purposely jumbled text of his Battle of the
Trees, which refers to a primitive British tradition of the
capture of an oracular shrine by the guessing of a god's name.
This capture seems to have taken place early in the fourth
century B.C. when the Belgic Brythons, worshippers of the
Ash-god Gwydion, with the help of an agricultural tribe already
settled in Britain, seized the national shrine, perhaps Avebury,
from the reigning priesthood, two of whose gods were Arawn
and Bran."
Thanks
go to Don Kuenz for this particular section.
1.C
- Who is Anakin's father?
Shmi
tells Qui-Gon that "there was no father"
and this leads him to believe that Anakin was "conceived
by the Midichlorians."
In Revenge of the Sith, Palpatine relates to Anakin the story
of Darth Plagueis the Wise who was so powerful he could influence
the Midichlorians to create life. The implication is that
Plagueis himself or possibly Sidious created Anakin but this
is never actually stated in the film. Although it seems likely
that Sidious had a hand in Anakin's creation, he was not entirely
truthful with Anakin in this particular conversation and could
well have been telling the boy what he knew he wanted to hear.
1.D
- Why does Obi-Wan in ESB say Yoda was his teacher but in
TPM it's Qui-Gon?
The
Jedi Apprentice series of books shows that Obi-Wan had other
teachers in the Jedi Temple before being made Qui-Gon's Padawan,
including various members of the Jedi Council. In a scene
from AOTC Obi-Wan goes to visit Yoda while he is teaching
a class of young Padawan learners. One of his former teachers,
Yoda, was referred to in a scene from the beginning of TPM:
"...but master Yoda said I should be mindful of the
future." This gives us a hint that Kenobi WAS taught
by Yoda but not in the way we first assumed from watching
ESB. It was, after all, said from a `certain point of view`.

1.E
- What's this about bringing balance to the Force?
Many
people get confused because they take the idea of balance
too literally. Lucas does not refer to an equality of numbers
like we might assume balance to mean; after all, a person
who is mentally balanced isn't half sane and half insane.
In his ideal universe there is no evil. On the original trilogy
VHS box set released in 2000 he explained what he means by
bringing balance to the Force. It entails eliminating the
Sith and having only Jedi, thereby bringing harmony to the
universe. Anakin is the Chosen One and although he is instrumental
in wiping out the Jedi he eventually brings balance to the
Force by utterly destroying the Sith once and for all. It's
important to remember that the Star Wars movies are fairy
tales not documentaries and therefore the rules of the tale
do not have to follow those in real life.
1.F
- Why doesn't Qui-Gon disappear?
Of
all the Jedi/Force bearing individuals that die we know of
only two that actually disappear upon death. George Lucas
has stated that "there is a whole issue around that
and the ability to disappear... the key line to understanding
this is when Ben Kenobi tells Darth Vader, 'If you strike
me down...'" Even though we saw Qui-Gon cremated
rather than disappear he was able to retain his identity after
death and his voice was heard by Yoda in AOTC when Anakin
slaughtered the Tusken Raiders. He then made contact with
Yoda in ROTS. In the novelization (page 409) Qui-Gon tells
Yoda the secret of eternal life. He says it is "the
ultimate goal of the Sith, yet they can never achieve it;
it comes only by the release of self, not the exaltation of
self. It comes through compassion, not greed. Love is the
answer to the darkness." Alone in his exile, the
ancient Jedi Master became his student learning how to become
one with the Force and live on after death.
"One
of the things that will never get explained in the films is
how Ben was able to retain his identity, because it happened
somewhere between the third and fourth movies. I set up that
this is a discipline that he learned from Yoda; Yoda told
him how to do that."
http://www.starwars.com/episode-vi/explore/classic/2001/07/classic20010730.html
1.G
- Was that Qui-Gon's voice that Yoda heard when Anakin killed
the Tusken Raiders?
Yes
it was Qui-Gon Jinn who said "Anakin! Anakin! No!"
The "Anakin" part of the line was from TPM when
Qui-Gon told Anakin to drop as Maul was pursuing them across
the desert.
1.H
- Who is Sifo-Dyas and who erased Kamino from the Jedi Archives?
Although
Sifo-Dyas was not on the Jedi Council during the events of
TPM he was certainly known to Obi-Wan, Yoda and Mace Windu.
According to the ROTS Visual Dictionary (2005) and the novel
Labyrinth of Evil (2005) he was a friend of Count Dooku. He
placed an order with the cloners of Kamino unbeknownst to
the Jedi Council. The book "Galactic Crisis!" by
Ryder Windham (2005) is not canon but reveals "Obi-Wan
later discovered that Palpatine himself sent the mysterious
Sifo-Dyas to Kamino to commission the vast clone army."
Under orders from his new master, Darth Sidious, Dooku killed
his former friend and took control of the clone operation;
recruiting Jango Fett and erasing all records of Kamino from
the Jedi Archives. There is no canon explanation so these
non-canon tidbits will have serve. Other theories, of impersonation
and dual identities, have been raised but seem inadequate
to explain what may really just be a case of betrayal and
Sith foresight.
1.I
- Why was Count Dooku surprised by the appearance of the clone
army when he knew Jango Fett?
Count
Dooku AKA Darth Tyranus was the person who recruited Jango
Fett to be the host for the clone army. He knew of the army's
existence and was only the leader of the separatist movement
because he was the apprentice of Darth Sidious whose plan
was to start a major war. Dooku pretended to be surprised
so that his identity and true purpose would not be known by
his "allies" in the separatist movement.
1.J
- What happened to Jango's unaltered clone?
Lama
Su told Obi-Wan Kenobi that "besides his payment,
which was considerable, Fett demanded only one thing - an
unaltered clone for himself." He named this unaltered
clone Boba and raised him as a son. The last we saw of him
in AOTC he was holding his father's helmet in his hands.
1.K
- If General Grievous is a droid why does he cough?
Grievous
is not a droid but a cybernetic organism or Cyborg. He was
once a great warrior of the Kaleesh people but after a shuttle
accident almost killed him his severely injured body was reconstructed
with mechanical parts transforming him into a being more powerful
than mere flesh. "His implacable metallic skeleton
gives him the aspect of a droid, but hidden inside the armoured
carapace is an unwholesome, living being. To remind viewers
of this inner Grievous, his words are occasionally punctuated
with a hard, wet hacking cough -- suggesting that Grievous
is literally rotten to the core." (Star Wars Homing
Beacon #128.) An alternate reason for the General's cough
is contained in Season 3 of the Clone Wars micro-series. In
Episode 25 Mace Windu uses the Force to crush Grievous' chest,
causing him to cough.
1.L
- Which is Palpatine's real face?
As
a result of his battle with Mace Windu we see a marked change
in Palpatine's face which raises the question of whether the
Force lightning damaged his face or simply tore away the mask
revealing his true face? The Visual Dictionary suggests that
Palpatine has two faces, one of which is his true face but
elsewhere it also says his face is "irreparably damaged."
Rick McCallum himself believes that Palpatine's wrinkled face
is his real one but hasn't claimed this to be the definitive
answer. George Lucas remains silent on the subject, perhaps
intending it to be ambiguous.
The
novelization gives two possible answers. "I shall
miss the face of Palpatine, I think; but for our purpose,
the face of Sidious will serve," says the Emperor
after Mace is dead. This apparently makes it clear that Sidious'
face is truly wrinkled, always was, but the description of
his transformation leaves room for doubt. "The yellow
glare from Palpatine's eyes spread outward through his flesh.
His skin flowed like oil, as though the muscle beneath was
burning away, as though even the bones of his skull were softening,
were bending and bulging, deforming from the heat and pressure
of his electric hatred." This doesn't sound like
somebody revealing their true identity but rather somebody
being exposed to energies which forever transform their appearance.
The official site says "he was severely scarred by
the reflected power of his dark side lightning."
http://www.starwars.com/databank/character/darthsidious/index.html
and if you closely examine every shot of Sidious throughout
the trilogy you'll see that his face is not deformed until
after his battle with Mace Windu. You can especially see this
in his conference with General Grievous. So does this answer
the question? That will have to be left to individual interpretation.
1.M
- How is Leia able to remember her mother when Padmé
died after childbirth?
Padmé
barely got to see her children before passing away from causes
unknown so it seems odd that Leia is able to remember her.
There is no canon explanation for this but fan speculation
has provided a couple of answers which one can either reject
or embrace. It's possible that Leia had a strong connection
with her mother through the Force which Luke, despite demonstrating
greater ability, did not. This connection could have left
a lasting impression on Leia thus allowing her to remember
her mother despite her infancy. Another possibility is that
Bail Organa raised Leia with the knowledge of who her real
mother was and therefore she could have seen images or recordings
of Padmé which gave rise to the memories she shares
with Luke. Others have suggested Leia is remembering her adopted
mother. Of course, it could be a giant plot hole which Lucas
carelessly left unanswered.
*2*
EPISODES IV - VI *2*
2.A
- Are Bail, Wedge and Captain Antilles related?
Bail
Antilles, Capt. Antilles and Wedge Antilles are not related
in any way.
Bail Antilles was Alderaan's representative in the Senate
during the Trade Federation's invasion of Naboo. He ran against
Palpatine for the office of Chancellor.
Capt. Antilles was originally named "Captain Colton,"
and this name appears in the novelization and early scripts.
Incidentally this is the name of the pilot of the Tantive
IV (played by Jeremy Bulloch in Revenge of the Sith). He was
also from Alderaan but is no relation to the former Senator.
Wedge Antilles is from Corellia. For more information on Wedge,
please visit the alt.fan.wedge news group. On the Official
Site Steve Sansweet explains "it should be noted that
`Antilles` is sort of the Star Wars equivalent of Jones,`
and `Smith.` There have been numerous characters throughout
the films, books and expanded universe material named Antilles,
but almost none of them are directly related."
2.B
- Didn't the droids belong to Wedge?
Captain
Antilles (not Wedge) was the man who Vader throttled in the
early parts of ANH and who was seen with Bail Organa in ROTS.
He was the owner of R2-D2 and C-3PO from the time he was entrusted
with them by Organa until his death.
2.C
- What does Darth Vader mean?
Some
fans have speculated that Darth stands for DARk lord of the
siTH but this has no known basis in fact. Possibly it was
chosen because it sounds like dark but once again this is
only speculation. It is much more likely than anything else
that it is a completely fictitious name. The word "Vader"
does mean "father" in Dutch. In the documentary
series "Joseph Campbell and the Power of Myth" George
Lucas states that he used the name Vader for this very reason.
It has also been noted that it brings to mind the word "invader."
2.D
- Why did Obi-Wan lie about the droids?
Obi-Wan
claimed "I don't seem to remember ever owning a droid"
yet he is plainly seen in the presence of both R2 and 3PO
in Episodes I-III. This does not mean he lied to Luke in ANH.
Obi-Wan merely said he didn't own a droid, he never said he
hadn't met the droids before. The two droids, R4-P17 and R4-G9
who are hardwired to Obi-Wan's Jedi Starfighters were not
owned by him but by the Jedi. Many people believe that his
first words to R2, "come here my little friend,"
are an indication that he did in fact recognize him. It must
be remembered though that there are innumerable astromech
and protocol droids in the SW universe and it has presumably
been many years since Obi-Wan last saw these two. Add to this
the fact that Obi-Wan often tells Luke the truth from his
own point of view and that there is no reason for him to tell
Luke about any past associations he may have had with the
droids that would undoubtedly lead to many awkward questions.
2.E
- Are Imperial Stormtroopers clones?
There
was at least one official source describing them as clones
back in the 1970s. We know that Clonetroopers are the forerunners
of the Imperial Stormtroopers we see in the original trilogy.
The question is did Palpatine continue using clones to populate
his army or did he recruit individuals? When Luke rescues
Leia, from her cell aboard the Death Star, she asks if he
isn't too short to be a Stormtrooper. While that may indicate
that men have to be at least a certain height before they
will be considered for the job, it could also mean that all
Stormtroopers are the same height because they are genetically
identical. The ROTS Visual Dictionary states "clones
are. being grown on other worlds, with cells procured from
new templates." Whether there are any clones of Jango
Fett still around at the time of the Galactic Civil War is
unknown and may never be revealed. It seems likely that at
least part of the Imperial armed forces is made up of clones.
2.F
- Why doesn't Owen recognize the droids in Episode IV?
Like
many questions this one can only be answered with speculation.
It's possible that Owen did recognize them and that's why
he was so insistent on having their memories erased. It's
also possible that there are so many droids in the galaxy
that he just never considered it likely that his new protocol
droid was the one he knew 22 years earlier. In AOTC C-3PO
is a dull silver colour but in ANH he's shiny gold. Then there's
the fact that he spent only a few seconds with them and never
learned their designations in ANH. Of course it could all
just be a major problem of inattention to continuity.
2.G
- When did Vader find out about Luke?
Here
is another question that has no canon answer. It is generally
accepted that Vader found out that the name of the Rebel who
destroyed the Death Star was Skywalker some time shortly following
the Battle of Yavin. In the comic book "Vader's Quest"
by Darko Macan the Sith Lord searches for the hero of Yavin
and learns from a Rebel that it was Luke Skywalker, his son,
who destroyed the Death Star. This is not contradicted by
canon and seems a very likely explanation. The 2004 DVD release
of ESB has Palpatine telling Vader of Luke Skywalker but from
the opening crawl we know that Vader is already obsessed with
finding Luke; so he obviously knows the identity of the Rebel
hero long before Palpatine does.
2.H
- Who said the numbers `3263827` in the Trash Compactor?
This
was one of the most controversial topics ever raised in AFS
and I include it here becuase I STILL disagree with the outcome.
Long time posters will recall the endless threads debating
this topic without resolution. Opinion has been divided over
whether it was Han or Luke who called out the numbers. Those
who believe it's Luke are certain it is Mark Hamill's voice
and add that Luke was the one holding the comlink. Those who
say Han point out that he was the only one in a position to
see the numbers by the door, that the numbers are only spoken
once and that only Han could have done this. The official
answer is that it is "Han Solo who shouts out `3263827!`
in response to Luke's query, `Where are we?`"
2.I
- What is Yoda?
There
are currently no canon/official sources which give a name
for Yoda's species although in TPM a female of Yoda's species,
named Yaddle, appears in the Jedi Council. This STILL doesn't
help answer the question though. Is he Reptilian? Is he Bird-like?
Some people have speculated that Yoda might be a member of
a race known as the Whills. The Whills were mentioned in the
preface of the novelization of ANH but there is no evidence
linking this unknown race to Yoda.
2.J
- Is the Emperor a Jedi? Who trained him?
Palpatine
was never a Jedi or his abilities would have been known to
Yoda and the Jedi Council. How he was trained in secret and
how he became so powerful are unknown but he was originally
from Naboo and his master was Darth Plagueis the Wise. Once
Palpatine had learned all he could from Darth Plagueis he
murdered his master in his sleep.
2.K
- How long was Luke on Dagobah?
This
is another question that can only be answered by saying "nobody
knows." No canon sources make it clear how long Luke
was on Dagobah (and, by association, how long the Millennium
Falcon took to get to Bespin). Many (seemingly expert) physics
student seem to have decided the whole situation is literally
impossible without light speed travel. There have been official
(but non-canon) sources that have treated this very subject.
In them the agreed upon length of time for Luke's stay on
Dagobah is given as "a few weeks" or "couple
of weeks." This would seem to mesh well with the
idea that, whereas a normal Jedi needed years to complete
training, Luke was an exceptional prospect and needed only
scant weeks to complete the same thing.
2.L
- Who originally played Emperor Palpatine in ESB?
Clive
Revill is credited as the VOICE of Palpatine but the face
is NOT Alec Guinness, as some would like to believe. It is
a woman with chimpanzee eyes super imposed to create the effect
we see with the Emperor in ESB. Ian McDiarmid, who plays the
Emperor in ROTJ and Palpatine/Sidious in the prequels, was
added to the release of ESB on DVD in 2004.
2.M
- In the Carbon Freezing Chamber scene in ESB, when Vader
says "I am altering the deal," does he use the Force
to choke Lando?
This
all depends on your own interpretation of the events witnessed
in that particular scene.
The
Script
LANDO: You said they'd be left in the city under my supervision.
VADER: I am altering the deal. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Lando's
hand instinctively goes to his throat as he turns to Leia,
Chewie, and Threepio.
Not
much there to give us a hint either way.
The
Novel
Indicating Leia and Chewbacca, Lando told Vader, "I'll
take what is mine now." He was determined to whisk
them out of Vader's clutches before the Dark Lord reneged
on their contract.
"Take
them," Vader said, "but I'm keeping a detachment
of troops here to watch over them."
"That wasn't part of the bargain," Lando
protested hotly. "You said the Empire wouldn't interfere
in -"
"I'm altering the bargain. Pray I don't alter it any
further."
A
sudden tightness grasped Lando's throat, a threatening sign
of what would happen to him if he gave Vader any difficulty.
Lando's hand automatically went to his neck, but in the next
moment the unseen hold was released and the administrator
turned to face Leia and Chewbacca.
There's
a little bit more to go on now. This clearly shows that Lando
was indeed choked by Vader as a warning.
The
Movie
This is where it gets complicated. The only indication that
we `think` Vader chokes Lando is when Lando puts his hand
to his neck after Vader has said, "I am altering the
deal. Pray I don't alter it any further." Some say
it's a gesture by Lando because he knows what COULD happen.
Some say it's obvious that Vader reaches, through the Force,
to choke Lando.
This
question can be debated but what it boils down to is personal
interpretation but personal interpretation DOES NOT make the
person correct.
Let's
look at, for the want of a better word, the Force Grip. It
is set up in ANH. It is then demonstrated in ESB on Admiral
Ozzel and Captain Needa. It sets up the scene with Lando,
so it's only natural to assume that Vader does indeed choke
Lando but, again, this is all based on the viewer's own interpretation,
so half say `yes` and half say `no`. Who is right? Who is
wrong? Will we ever know?! ;-)

2.N
- Are Obi-Wan and Owen Lars brothers?
In
the ROTJ novelization Obi-Wan tells Luke that Owen is his
brother. This is in most versions of the script, and is rumoured
to have been filmed but edited out of the final copy of ROTJ.
The novelization is a canon source but can be contradicted
by the movies. When writing AOTC George Lucas made Owen Anakin's
step-brother and now he is no relation of Obi-Wan's. From
the official site - "Owen Lars is the son of Cliegg
Lars. Obi-Wan's parents are unknown, and he has little to
no connection to them having grown up in the Jedi Temple."
2.O - Did Boba Fett really die in ROTJ?
According
to George Lucas, Boba Fett is dead. He, and most people are
aware of the different stories that have Fett surviving the
Sarlacc.
There are about 3 different versions of this story. He has
stated in interviews that, "I killed Boba Fett. He
is dead." But in one of the most recent interviews
he has said he has toyed with the idea of inserting a little
shot of him escaping. If he'd known how popular Fett would
become perhapos he may have been a bit kinder to the old buckethead!
*3*
MISCELLANEOUS *3*
3.A
- What is meant by "canon"?
Well,
when you get right down to the basics of any expanded universe,
such as that of Star Wars, Star Trek, or even Babylon 5, the
questions are raised as to what items are considered a part
of the overall story, which are "sort of" a part
of it, and which just plain aren't part of the mainstream
saga in the least. In a situation like this, the terms "canon,"
"official," "unofficial," "apocrypha,"
and "fan fiction" come into play.
As
far as level of priority and officialty, the ladder, from
greatest priority to least is:
First
Level Canon
Second Level Canon
Third Level Canon
Fourth Level Canon
Official (Expanded Universe)
Apocrypha (Unofficial)
Fan Fiction (FanFic)
`CANON`
is that which is undeniably part of the overall story, the
creator's vision. In the case of Star Wars, this is broken
down into four levels, with the lower levels being only canonical
so far as that they do not contradict the higher levels. Essentially,
the lower levels are only canonical where they agree with,
or add to, the higher levels. `First Level Canon` is the highest
level of officialty that something can receive. This term
is reserved solely for Lucas' definitive vision and includes
only these items:
Star
Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace
Star Wars: Episode II - Attack Of The Clones
Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith
Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope (2004 DVD Edition)
The Star Wars Holiday Special
Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back (2004 DVD Edition)
Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi (2004 DVD Edition)
Caravan Of Courage (AKA The Ewok Adventure)
Ewoks: The Battle For Endor
`Second
Level Canon` is the next level down from the creator's definitive
vision. It basically consists of anything that the creator
originally considered First Level Canon, but overwrote slightly.
In this case, the original Star Wars film trilogy and the
Special Editions fit into this category. Second Level Canon
information can only be overridden by First Level Canon (i.e.,
if an "official continuity" author had written that
Greedo shot first in A New Hope, it would have not been the
"way it really happened," but since Lucas overwrote
that scene with his definitive, First Level Canon Special
Edition, the old version of events ceased to exist, and were
replaced by those Lucas created with his First Level Canon).
Essentially, anything in the original films is canonical,
unless it contradicts the First Level Canon of the Special
Edition. (The SE scripts are included in this category.)
`Third
Level Canon` is the next step below the original films. This
level includes the novelizations of the films themselves.
This level can only be overridden by First or Second Level
Canon. Thus, if a wording is different in the novel than in
the film, the novelization wording is not canonical. For example,
in the novelization to The Empire Strikes Back, Han Solo,
while fleeing Hoth, states, "I know, I know, I see them,"
when referring to Star Destroyers. In the films (both First
and Second Level Canon versions), he states "I saw 'em!
I saw 'em!" Nitpicky, yes, but by the rules of canonicity,
the film wording supersedes the novelization. (The original
version scripts are included in this category.)
`Fourth
Level Canon` is the final step down the ladder of officialty
before one reaches simply "official." This level
includes the radio dramas of the Star Wars films and the Clone
Wars animated series. Once again, it is a case of these events
being canonical only so far as they add to or agree with the
films and novelizations. The novels and both versions of the
films supersede these. For example, the Battle of Derra IV
in the ESB radio drama is canonical because it adds to, and
does not contradict, the films or novelizations. The character
of Heater in the ANH radio drama is not canonical, as that
character is replaced with a different character name in the
Third, Second, and First Level Canon.
`Official`
is that which Lucasfilm has allowed to become a part of their
"official continuation." George Lucas himself does
not approve these stories and has stated that he feels no
obligation to work any of these elements into his future films.
This is essentially a collection of stories licensed by Lucasfilm
and produced by Bantam Spectra, Berkley Boulevard, Del Rey,
Berkley Boulevard, Berkley Jam, Dark Horse Comics, LucasArts
games (in some, but not all cases), and other companies that
Lucasfilm has allowed to contribute to the continuity. This
is what most current Star Wars saga fans consider the timeline,
although that may change if and when Lucas overrides them
by producing a Sequel Trilogy, which would be First Level
Canon.
`Apocrypha`
(often referred to as Unofficial) refers to any and all Star
Wars stories that are not a part of the "official continuity."
The stories may form timelines unto themselves, but they are
not Lucasfilm- approved for the continuity. It's safest to
consider them "alternate reality" versions of the
saga. They have no place in the "official continuity."
`Fan
Fiction` (or FanFic) is the term that refers to any creation
by a Star Wars fan that is not sanctioned by Lucasfilm in
any form. (Apocryphal items at least got permission to publish.)
These are things like Troops and other fan-created videos,
short stories like Bantha Squadron, etc. If you've ever written
or created a Star Wars story on your own, that item would
be called FanFic, or Fan Fiction.
From
the Star Wars Insider #23, an interview with Production and
Continuity Editors Sue Rostoni and Allan Kausch:
"Gospel,
or canon as we refer to it, includes the screenplays, the
films, the radio dramas, and the novelizations. These works
spin out of George Lucas' original stories, the rest are written
by other writers. However, between us, we've read everything,
and much of it is taken into account in the overall continuity.
The entire catalog of published works comprises a vast history
-- with many off-shoots, variations and tangents like any
other well-developed mythology." This is the end-all
and the be-all of the Star Wars Universe. The original novels,
comics, WEG material, etc. ARE "official," meaning
that it has been licensed and approved by Lucasfilm. However,
there are times when they have contradicted the canon sources,
such as with the Death and Life of Boba Fett (see item 2.O.)
In such instances, the "official" sources
are to be disregarded.
Here
is LucasBooks' Chris Cerasi's answer from the official site:
There's been some confusion of late regarding the 'Infinities'
symbol and Star Wars Expanded Universe continuity in general.
Terms like "canon" and "continuity" tend
to get thrown around casually, which doesn't help at all.
When it comes to absolute canon, the real story of Star Wars,
you must turn to the films themselves - and only the films.
Even novelizations are interpretations of the film, and while
they are largely true to George Lucas' vision (he works quite
closely with the novel authors), the method in which they
are written does allow for some minor differences. The novelizations
are written concurrently with the film's production, so variations
in detail do creep in from time to time. Nonetheless, they
should be regarded as very accurate depictions of the fictional
Star Wars movies. The further one branches away from the movies,
the more interpretation and speculation come into play. LucasBooks
works diligently to keep thecontinuing Star Wars expanded
universe cohesive and uniform, but stylistically, there is
always room for variation. Not all artists draw Luke Skywalker
the same way. Not all writers define the character in the
same fashion. The particular attributes of individual media
also come into play. A comic book interpretation of an event
will likely have less dialogue ordifferent pacing than a novel
version. A video game has to take an interactive approach
that favors gameplay. So too must card and roleplaying games
ascribe certain characteristics to characters and events in
order to make them playable. The analogy is that every piece
of published Star Wars fiction is a window into the 'real'
Star Wars universe. Some windows are a bit foggier than others.
Some are decidedly abstract. But each contains a nugget of
truth to them. Like the great Jedi Knight Obi-Wan Kenobi said,
'many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our point
of view.'
Returning
to the question at hand. Yes, "Star Wars Gamer"
is part of continuity, though as game material, there is room
for interpretation. Only specific articles marked with the
'Infinities' logo within the magazine should be considered
out of continuity. Fans of the old monthly Marvel Star Wars
comic will be heartened to know that LucasBooks does indeed
consider them part of continuity. Decades of retrospect haven't
been kind to all the elements of the comic series, but the
characters and events still hold weight and are referenced
in newer material whenever possible. In order to allow unlimited
freedom of storytelling, the Infinities label has been placed
on the anthology series, "Star Wars Tales". This
means that not only can the stories occur anywhere in the
Star Wars timeline, but stories can happen outside continuity.
Basically, if an event happens in "Tales", it may
not have necessarily happened in the rest of the expanded
universe. For some stories, the distinction is largely inconsequential.
For others, it's the only way they could exist.
3.B
- Will there be episodes 7-9?
Although
the range of EU books seems likely to continue forever and
there will be at least two new TV series set in the Star Wars
universe, contrary to what many people believe/hope, there
are no plans for a third trilogy comprising Episodes 7-9.
At a press conference in Australia, Rick McCallum, long-time
collaborator with George Lucas and Producer of the Prequel
Trilogy, announced that George Lucas himself has decided that
Episodes 1-6 are the totality of his Star Wars story, and
that the time period AFTER the Prequels have been released
are likely to find Lucas and Lucasfilm working on more experimental
types of projects.
3.C
- Missing scenes?
Most
of these "missing scenes" that people claim
to have seen don't exist. There are a few scenes which were
filmed but never made it beyond the cutting room floor including
some extra scenes depicting Luke and Biggs on Tatooine in
ANH, a scene involving C-3PO and the removal of a warning
sign, and the extra footage removed from TPM but included
on the DVD.
3.D
- What is "Troops"?
"Troops"
is a parody of both SW and the TV show, "COPS,"
that uses Stormtroopers. It was written and directed by Kevin
Rubio. Troops can be downloaded at http://www.theforce.net/fanfilms/shortfilms/troops/.
It is distributed free of charge and it is illegal for anyone
to sell or trade it for profit. And yes, George Lucas has
seen it, and he thought it was hilarious.
3.E
- What is the "Star Wars Holiday Special"?
Long
ago, in an era far, far away... a television special featuring
Wookiees, C-3PO, and a stoned Carrie Fisher aired on network
TV. It seems that in his old age George Lucas has looked back
at the Star Wars Holiday Special that aired in 1978 and decided
the world would have been a better place if he had never made
it. He's publicly said that if he could, he would find all
copies circulating loosely and destroy them. So no, don't
plan on seeing the SW Holiday Special on TV or in video stores
any time soon. Bootleg versions are available online or at
conventions.
3.F
- Mark Hamill's accident.
In
1976 Mark Hamill was involved in a car accident near his home
in Southern California. He required some reconstructive surgery
which is why his face, particularly his nose, is different
in ESB. Contrary to popular belief the Wampa scenes in ESB
were not written into the movie as a way to explain his facial
scars; it's just a coincidence.
3.G
- How do you spell litesabber....lightsaybr....lights...pagh!!!
There
seems to be some confusion as to the correct spelling of Lightsaber/Lightsabre.
The Original Star Wars Novel by George Lucas (ghost written
by Alan Dean Foster) has the spelling as Lightsaber as does
the Return of the Jedi Novel, by James Kahn and The Phantom
Menace Novel, by Terry Brooks but The Empire Strikes Back
Novel, by Donald. F. Glut, has the spelling Lightsabre. After
checking the Official Site - Weapons Section, it does seem
that the general consensus for the `laser sword` is Lightsaber,
so, there you have it, LIGHTSABER!!
3.H
- I've heard such and such happens in the novels/graphic novels
but which one?
i)
In what story did Luke Skywalker and Mara Jade marry?
Luke
And Mara became engaged in the 'Vision of the Future' novel
by Timothy Zahn and married in the comic series `SW:Union`
published by Dark Horse comics.
ii)
In what story did Luke Skywalker turn to the Dark Side?
Luke
was seduced to the Dark Side in the `Dark Empire` graphic
novel series. He is later recovered by Leia.
iii)
In what story did Emperor Palpatine return as a clone?
Again
in `Dark Empire`, a clone of Palpatine is discovered, who
then succeeds in turning Luke to the Dark Side (see above).
The clone story also continues in "Dark Empire 2"
and "Empire's End".
3.I
- What time period do the films cover and what are the ages
of the major characters?
Using
the first movie released, Episode IV, as the starting point
the chronology of the movies goes thus:
TPM
-32
AOTC -22
ROTS -19
ANH 0
ESB +3
ROTJ +4
According
to the novelization of TPM Anakin was 9 years old; Padmé
was 14; Obi-Wan was 25 and Qui-Gon was 60. This makes Anakin
45 at the time of his death in ROTJ and Obi-Wan 57 at the
time of his death in ANH. In ANH Luke and Leia were 19 and
Han was, according to the novelization, "perhaps five
years older than Luke, perhaps a dozen."
3.J
- Why can't I get the original unaltered trilogy on DVD?
George
Lucas had many constraints to contend with when making the
original trilogy. The technology of filmmaking was well behind
his vision and so he had to leave things incomplete due to
problems of time and money. Years later he decided to revisit
these movies and discovered that "it was so badly damaged.
[They] had to digitally scan the images. Once that happened,
George had the unique opportunity to then go back and say,
wait a second, I've always been embarrassed by this film.
Now he's [able] to go back and make the film that he always
wanted to achieve in the first place." (Rick McCallum
SUM (Specifiek Universitair Magazine), vol. 7, no. 3) So now,
in George Lucas' mind, the Special Editions are the movies
that he always wanted to make and the original versions are
no longer relevant. The last time the original versions were
released was on VHS and laser disc in 1995. *However, on May
3, 2006, Lucasfilm announced on the official Star Wars site
that due to "overwhelming demand," the original
versions would be released on DVD on September 12, 2006. Each
film was released as a two-disc set with the 2004 versions
of the films on one disc, and the original, unaltered film
on the second disc, as a bonus feature. The set was available
until December 31, 2006, when it was withdrawn from the market.
There
has been controversy surrounding this release, since it was
revealed that the DVDs featured non-anamorphic versions of
the original, unaltered films based on laserdisc releases
from 1993 (as opposed to newly-remastered, film-based transfers).
Since non-anamorphic transfers fail to make full use of the
resolution available on widescreen sets, many fans were upset
over this choice. The laserdisc releases utilized the PCM
format for the stereo soundtrack, while the DVDs contain the
more compressed Dolby Digital 2.0 format. Dolby Digital is
a mandatory format for DVD, but the lack of the superior PCM
format is also upsetting to some fans. So, this question is
STILL a valid one.
*From Wikipedia
3.K
- What does EU stand for?
EU
means Expanded Universe or Extended Universe. It refers to
the ever increasing amount of fictional works which expand
on the characters, worlds and situations created by George
Lucas in his movies. They include such things as novels, comics
and games. These works are official but Lucas has no immediate
involvement in their creation. (See item 3.A for more.)
3.L
- Easter Eggs?
An
"Easter Egg" is a little surprise placed in a production
by its creator. In this case, GL included quite a few little
tidbits in his newest Star Wars movies. In TPM there are Wookiees,
an appearance by Warwick Davis, a THX reference and the sound
of Darth Vader breathing. In AOTC, when Anakin and Padmé
arrive on Naboo, some ships that look suspiciously like the
Millennium Falcon can be seen in the bottom left of the frame
and both Anthony Daniels (C-3PO) and Ahmed Best (Jar Jar Binks)
play patrons in the nightclub scene. In ROTS, when Anakin
visits Palpatine at the opera, George Lucas himself can be
seen standing outside the doorway which Anakin enters. A comprehensive
list of Easter Eggs in ROTS can be found at
http://www.starwars.com/episode-iii/bts/production/f20050526/index.html.
3.M
- Did Mark Hamill shout "Carrie" in Episode IV?
Urban
Legends
Actors
do make mistakes. They are, after all, humans (even the computer-generated
ones, at heart). Since so much work has to go into turning
an on-set performance into a finished Star Wars movie, mistakes
can be caught and fixed by the many people who handle the
film after the shooting is done. Much of the sound heard in
Star Wars was created and crafted after the action had been
shot. Though on-set microphones captured the live performance
as it occurred, many times actors had to come back in to loop
dialog. Even dialog that is captured on set is carefully mixed
and massaged by sound editors to achieve a certain consistency
and interaction with other added sound effects. In the end,
so many people scrutinize the audio recording that it seems
unlikely that such a gaff could have gotten through.
So,
while it indeed sounds like "Carrie!" to many people,
in the finished film, that's not what Mark Hamill says. What
does he say? While putting together the improved soundtrack
for the Special Edition Trilogy, sound editor Ben Burtt investigated
the matter. All the original tracks, 1/4-inch tapes, and source
materials were pulled out from storage, and listened to in
a big mix room at Skywalker Sound. "We made loops out
of everything Mark said and played them for a panel of listeners,"
says Burtt. "We edited the recording and filtered it
and did everything we could to clean up the phrase where he
yells as he hugs Princess Leia."
The
audio investigation included numerous takes of Mark Hamill
recording that scene. "The consensus was that he is yelling
'hey' or 'yay,' rather than 'Carrie.' In other takes he specifically
yells 'yay!' at that point," explains Burtt. "Like
most garbled dialog, if you listen to it over and over with
all the other voices in there you can convince yourself that
he is saying 'Carrie' or any number of things. But we were
convinced that he really was just cheering." According
to Mark Hamill, he excitedly yells "Hey! There she is!"
indicating that Luke was scanning the rushing crowd for Leia.
In the excitement, Luke doesn't stop to enunciate each syllable
like a certain golden protocol droid would do. "I ended
up swallowing the 'is' part," says Hamill. So the end
result was garbled to the point that some people believe it
sounds an awful lot like "Carrie!" So much so that
even those closely involved in the production can hear that
if they listen to it enough times.
Contributions
by: Bags; John Donchig; Guardian; Don Kuenz; Chris Pastor;
SGHB; PhantomShadow; Nathan Butler; Brett McConnie and Karrde.
END
OF FAQ |