I can remember..........only just.....Episode 1....Many things I block from certain areas of my brain, but, remember 'Wipe them out, all of them', the first thing about the film that sounded 'goooooooud', these are but a few things that made a life long fan so attracted to the fresh feel Star Wars movies, please share your memories of the best and worst, no Gungan debates please, we've been there already;)

Best: Sidious.

Every scene he just oozed Palpiness !

Worst: Panaka

Every scene he just oozed cackness !

TPM was brilliant. Could only be better if Padme was played by Tanya Roberts instead

lol.

Best: Obi-Wan + Qui'Gon vs. Darth Maul. Still the unique part of the film saga.

Worst: Anakin Skywalker. Sounded like a whiny brat.

Best thing for me, is obi-wan vs maul, after qui-gons death.

Worst thing, the entire pod race, too long and too cartoony.

He's Nine Years old!!! OF COURSE HE'S A WHINY BRAT

Heh Heh !

If my kid is like that at 9, I'm going to kill her. ::

Oh yeah, and welcome to the boards.

Best of Episode I - Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon vs. Darth Maul; Darth Sidious

Worst of Episode I - I don't know. I think I agree that the pod race was too long. It would have been better if it had been about 2/3 that length.

Re: whiny nine year old - I didn't find him that bad. I've seen worse. Of course, I'm a music teacher, so maybe that's why. He seemed pretty typical for a kid. I think it is more the timbre of his voice that is off-putting for people. But little boys sound like little boys, not like evil overlords. Not that some aren't evil. But Anakin wasn't supposed to be evil at that time.

Hmm.. I LOVED the podrace, and I loved the duel at the end, I loved Palpy.....to be honest not much about the film I don't like, I may have seen it through rose tinted specs tho afetr flying to US to see it before its release here....kind of got caught up iin the moment

As one guy said at work, I enjoy the whole package so I can accept some of the minor niggles.

Loved the introduction of the Jedi at the beginning but didn't like the Gungan city and really didn't like the battle droids saying 'Roger Roger' What was that about?

George has funny ideas sometimes!

dont know about any1 else but i thought maul's line was great:"at last we can reveal ourselves to the jedi, at last we can have revenge"

Episode 1 was a terrible film that was aimed solely at creating new fans. It contained very little for fans of the original trilogy to enjoy. However i agree that the lightsabre fight between qui-gon, obi-wan and Darth Maul was very entertaining and provided one of the sagas best lightsabre duels

Best: Darth Maul and Sidious

Worst: Not enough Maul, too much Panaka, and too much over-the-top Jar Jar stupidity.

The movie is so much better when you're drunk and with drunk friends... man... that was fun.


The puking the next day - unrelated to the movie - was not so fun though.


The first thing I usually say when people ask about these movies is: "What movies?" .)

I thought his character was just ... blah.

If he hadn't been in the film ... would anyone have noticed? Probably not.

As to the Jar Jar, I not a die-hard Jar Jar hater. He was the comic relief for the movie. I just think if it had been done without the overwhelming over-the-top stupidity and antics, just toned it down some, there wouldn't be so much rampant Jar Jar hatred out there.

Best was Qui Gon and the introduction to the Jedi Council. Maul was an excellent addition as well.

Worst Not much but if I have to find something I would replace some gungan for more lightsabers.