[i] [i]
[MDA]    Add to Google    [NAS]    
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
GEN Site Nav
SW Galaxy Map
The Outlander Club
Features
Fan Fiction
Star Wars Fonts
Star Wars Scripts
Star Wars Soundbytes
EMP TV
G.E.N Links
Star Wars FAQ

Images >>>

Novel Time-Line
Artwork & Concepts
A Long Time Ago...
Collections - eFx & MR
Collections - Kotobukiya
Collections - Misc
Celebration Europe
Charity & Events
@ The Barbican
Spoof Park
Fan Art
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Get UBB
UBB
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Shout Box

[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Recent Topics
Squishies!
by Darth Palpy
1 second ago
Predators - Sneak Peek
by Darth Palpy
16/03/2010 07:29 AM
Avatar On Blu-Ray and DVD - UK 26th April
by Darth Palpy
16/03/2010 07:07 AM
Senate Murders Screen Caps
by Darth Palpy
14/03/2010 09:52 AM
Senate Murders Airs in UK First
by Darth Palpy
14/03/2010 07:41 AM
Making Episode I - Part Two
by Darth Palpy
13/03/2010 03:37 PM
Empire Chronicles
by Darth Palpy
13/03/2010 01:14 PM
Stormtrooper Super Shogun Early Bird Fnal Week
by Darth Palpy
12/03/2010 06:32 AM
Rest In Peace John G Bramley 1980-2010
by Patricia
03/03/2010 02:40 PM
Post counts are down...
by Patricia
03/03/2010 02:37 PM
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Search Internet
Custom Search
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Who's Online
1 registered (Darth Palpy), 8 Guests and 9 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Mod
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Newest Members
DarthEge, gary, Doc, squinter, OwenWill
240 Registered Users
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Forum Stats
240 Members
16 Forums
1501 Topics
5799 Posts

Max Online: 157 @ 06/07/2007 09:22 PM
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Featured Member
Registered: 22/01/2007
Posts: 48
[i] [i]
New Reply
Topic Options
[i] [i]
#8996 - 30/09/2007 11:28 PM Original or Redone
Darth Palpy Online   content
Loveable Tyrant
Registered: 12/12/2006
Posts: 1546
Loc: Big tower type-thingy
Do you like the Original or Redone version of A New Hope best?
[i] [i]
Original or Redone
Only one choice allowed


Votes accepted starting: 30/09/2007 11:27 PM
View the results of this poll.
[i] [i]
_________________________
PALPY
My Collection @ Rebelscum


"A Long Long Galaxy, Far, Far Away..."
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Google
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#9003 - 01/10/2007 07:17 AM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Darth Palpy]
Darth Revenge Offline
Living Dead Sith
Registered: 01/08/2007
Posts: 234
Loc: France
I prefer the redone version...
Still regret the very bad french translation...
_________________________
Imperial Revenge !
Darth 'Living Dead' Revenge - Hate Master
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#9005 - 01/10/2007 08:05 AM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Darth Revenge]
Nootch Offline
TK-5155
Registered: 21/09/2007
Posts: 265
Loc: Whitley Bay, England
philistine.

the original is best...

Han shot first.
_________________________
"Take an optimist, and a pessimist, then ask them which one is dissapointed more often!"
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#9022 - 01/10/2007 10:23 AM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Nootch]
slxception Offline
Please don't eat the Sith
Registered: 30/01/2007
Posts: 632
Loc: Lost on Earth
lol. I voted original though it was a close call. On some of the other ones, the original is clearly better.
_________________________

To be Frank with you, Sith happens! Deal with it. | Homepage
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#9069 - 02/10/2007 08:41 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: slxception]
Adrian666 Offline
Newbie
Registered: 01/10/2007
Posts: 14
Loc: New York
new one has better graphic and the same story line
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#9070 - 02/10/2007 09:46 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Adrian666]
Pruneface Offline
Shopkeep
Registered: 19/09/2007
Posts: 29
I think the tweaks in the digitally re-mastered versions certainly add to the enjoyment. For example in ANH the 'Search for the droids' and 'Mos Eisley' scenes are pretty cool, the more realistic explosions of course also add to the feel. Really when you think about it even un-touched The Trilogy hasn't dated. Long Live The Original Trilogy.......
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#11097 - 18/09/2008 09:37 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Pruneface]
Patricia Offline
Dark Lady of the Sith
Registered: 13/12/2006
Posts: 554
Loc: Northern Virginia, USA
I prefer the redone ANH and the redone trilogy. Though I still think it was better when Han shot first.
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#11144 - 05/10/2008 08:20 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Patricia]
Nootch Offline
TK-5155
Registered: 21/09/2007
Posts: 265
Loc: Whitley Bay, England
i agree with pruneface, certain elements from the redone versions improve them, and others spoil it. not a fan of the jabba music vid or the end tune in jedi.

but things like the clearer view of the wampa and the more detailed bespin are way better than they were.
_________________________
"Take an optimist, and a pessimist, then ask them which one is dissapointed more often!"
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#11286 - 17/11/2008 09:28 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Nootch]
Darth Psycho Offline
Junior Representative
Registered: 12/12/2007
Posts: 76
Loc: Worcester
original, at the end of the day that was the version that started everything so there couldn't of been to much wrong with it
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#11287 - 17/11/2008 09:30 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Darth Psycho]
Darth Psycho Offline
Junior Representative
Registered: 12/12/2007
Posts: 76
Loc: Worcester
Also I did enjoy it being on ITV yesterday. Its funny because even though I can (and do) watch it on dvd anytime I still always have to watch it if its on terrestrial
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#11357 - 12/12/2008 11:20 AM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Darth Psycho]
Nootch Offline
TK-5155
Registered: 21/09/2007
Posts: 265
Loc: Whitley Bay, England
my missus wouldn't let me watch it on the telly.
_________________________
"Take an optimist, and a pessimist, then ask them which one is dissapointed more often!"
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
#11367 - 14/12/2008 12:08 PM Re: Original or Redone [Re: Nootch]
Darth Psycho Offline
Junior Representative
Registered: 12/12/2007
Posts: 76
Loc: Worcester
oh the spoil sport
Top Reply Quote Quick Reply Quick Quote
[i] [i]

[i] [i]
Quick Reply:
HTML is disabled
UBBCode is disabled



[i] [i]



[i] [i]
SW CV / SW In Concert
Star Wars Celebration V

Star Wars In Concert
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Affiliates
Wookieepedia
Jedi News
Imperial Revenge
Star Wars Rebellion
The EU Cantina
Imperial Outpost
TPU
Jedi News Canada
FERA
[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Palpys Picks


501st TK Project
MiT
Imperial Distribution
Galactic Binder
Star Wars Atom Films
DK Books
TFN Podcast
Official Pix
The Force.Net

[i] [i]
[i] [i]
Random Images
Opening Day
506/thumbs/ce-1.jpg
264 views
Added by Darth Palpy

Coruscant
502/thumbs/coruscantb2.jpg
387 views
Added by Darth Palpy

Episode I Poster
502/thumbs/poster.jpg
308 views
Added by Darth Palpy

Storyboard
502/thumbs/storybm.jpg
277 views
Added by Darth Palpy

The Threat Within
503/thumbs/23-ttw.jpg
344 views
Added by Darth Palpy

[i] [i]
[i] [i]
[i] [i]



Online Since February 6th, 1999. Best Viewed : 1024x768 Screen Res - Broadband - Firefox browser. This site is Designed/Maintained by SGH-B © 1999-2009 G.E.N. All Rights Reserved
Not Affiliated or Endorsed by Lucasfilm, Ltd. Visit StarWars.Com